DESPOT WATCH: Muammer Muhammed Qadhafi
From The National Interest
November 4, 2003
I'm sad to report that our favorite despot of northern
Africa has turned a little jowly in recent years. He's lost that
Neal Diamond Grecian-bust look he had going on in his
revolutionary youth, and when he loads himself up with military
sashes and decorated pockets and epaulets and that broad-brimmed
braided cap, the Colonel resembles nothing so much as an
officious constable in a Gilbert & Sullivan operetta. Maybe he's
doing it on purpose. Maybe it's the new kinder, gentler friendly-
guy-next-door Qadhafi. The title of "Colonel," after all, WAS
conferred by the Brits. What kind of guy goes through life
WANTING to be the Colonel? We associate it with Colonel Sanders,
not to mention Colonel Klink. It's the daft blundering guy who
never quite makes general.
But then again, I think it's just Muammer's version of
modesty--as much as he can muster anyway. He's always struck me
as a guy who was not entirely comfortable addressing a Popular
Congress, and I suspect he's spirited away a few Cuban Cohibas
over the years. In this brave new world of post-Lockerbie Libya--
no sanctions, no embargoes, and the creation of a Libyan TOURISM
ministry, of all things--I can almost imagine Muammer settling
down into a Lazy-Boy recliner in his Hush Puppies and channel-
surfing from time to time. His recent speeches have even shown a
disturbing familiarity with the Internet. The mind boggles: "Hey,
whassup, peeps! I can be kinda wild, but I'm really an easygoing
guy who likes to cuddle."
Is it possible? Has the Q-man gone soft? Does the Director
of Secret Operations knock on his tent flap in Benghazi and say,
"Sir, we have three troublesome emigres in Paris. Would you like
us to send The Squad?" And does Qadhafi then say, "Oh, you know
what, that's so SEVENTIES. Just run some articles in the Tripoli
papers saying they have sex with dogs or something."
Of course, Qadhafi has always been the most mysterious of
all pariahs. He has homes all over Libya, but chances are you'll
find no Saddam-style golden saunas or hideaways for assignations
with porn stars. Qadhafi is the Ward Cleaver of international
dictators. He had that first brief marriage in the seventies,
then he found the girl of his Islamic dreams and stayed with her
through five children who went through angst-ridden teenage
years. If he'd had his heart in being a true Mohammedan super-
despot, he would have had five wives and attendant offspring
spread out all over the desert. Instead, he's got all these
disappointing sons who are bored by the idea of being the next
"Guide of the Revolution" and want to open car dealerships and go
to football games instead, and the only family member with an eye
for politics is his daughter Aisha, who shops in London and Paris
and COULD actually run the country--the Arab heads of state like
her that much--but he would have to go through some kind of
Shariah Hell to make that happen.
Still, everything we know about Qadhafi is seen through a
fuzzy curtain. He's always been so exotically remote to us that
he even has a name that's impossible to pronounce, or to write in
English. The man is a Google nightmare. Various attempts have
been Gadhafi, Gadaffi, Gaddafi, Gadhdhafi, Kaddafi, Kadhdhafi,
Khadafy, Qadaffi, Qaddafi, Qadhafi, Qadhdhafi, and Qathafi, but
no one really knows whether it's a "G" or a "Q" and where all the
h's go. His official biography is remarkably devoid of details
about his early years--probably because they were spent
organizing various cells plotting murder and revolutionary
mayhem--but it always begins with "born in a desert tent near
Surt." I've always suspected that the constant mention of Surt is
an attempt to identify Qadhafi with the nation's main source of
wealth--its oil fields--which lie in and around Surt and were not
discovered until 1959, but were obviously squandered until a
proper Surtite could marshall their economic power, primarily by
seizing everything the Brits and Americans had built there. (The
only American company, by the way, that stood up to Qadhafi's
nationalization of the oil fields was the privately held Hunt Oil
of Texas. Nelson Bunker Hunt harrassed Libya in every court in
the world until the Colonel finally wrote him a check to get rid
of him. Apparently Bunker and Muammer understand each other.)
What we do know is that Qadhafi had no special interest in
being a soldier except as a means to an end. He seems to have
been obsessed with revolution even when clad in knee breeches at
the British-style Sabha prep school in Fezzan. (You can imagine
his entry in the class yearbook. "Hobby: deposing the monarch.")
Following the example of his idol, Gamal Abdul Nasser, he entered
the Military Academy in Benghazi, where his first secret corps
was formed. He went on to the royal military academy in
Sandhurst, where he and his confederates took blood oaths to oust
King Idris I. As it turned out, it wasn't that big a deal. The
1969 coup is always described as simple and "bloodless." Idris
was part of the discredited and all but forgotten Senoussi
monarchy installed by the allies after World War II, so there was
no way he could be seen by the people as anything but a stooge of
foreign interests. His real battle came afterwards, when he had
to defeat the older officers who helped him but thought 27 was a
little young to be donning the Fearless Leader hat. It took him
three more months to turn them out.
Libya has such a strange history--shifting borders, Bedouin
politics, dozens of foreign masters, literally redrawing lines in
sand--that it has remained suspicious of ALL foreigners, even
those who would be the equivalent of what Canadians are to
America (Egyptians, Tunisians, Chadians). Most African countries
have staged some kind of jihad against European imperalists--
British imperialists, French imperialists, Dutch imperialists,
Belgian imperialists--but Libya is the only one to harbor
everlasting hatred for ITALIAN imperialists. Libya is, in fact,
one of Italy's only foreign adventures, and a disastrous one at
that. One of the first things commander-in-chief Qadhafi did in
1970 was to expel all the Italians that King Idris had failed to
drive out 25 years earlier, including the ones that had lasted
three generations. (He even had the graves of their ancestors dug
up and their bones disposed of.) He followed that up by ousting
the Jews, then closing the United States air base at Tripoli and
the British barracks at Azizia. Inside those barracks today is
Qadhafi's official tent, decorated on the inside with embroidered
weavings of Qadhafi's famous sayings, but on the outside drab and
unadorned, with a couple of picturesque camels tethered nearby
for the desired effect on foreign visitors.
With the nation properly cleansed of pasta, blintzes, kidney
pie and hamburgers, the Bedouin Zealot then set out to be the
kind of man that only Lawrence of Arabia could appreciate. He
believed in a true confederation of all Arab states, joined
together under Islamic law in a union so strong they would become
a third superpower. He was, in short, that most dangerous of
dictators, the true believer. He set out his views in The Green
Book (all three volumes now conveniently available on Qadhafi's
personal website), and we should give the man credit for being
one of the most concise prose stylists in the history of
tyrannical lunacy. You can actually read the entire Green Book in
half an afternoon, and, although he would not like this
characterization, most of it is Communism Lite. He rails AGAINST
Communism, of course, because he was trying to adapt a socialist
society to fit with Shariah Law, which wouldn't condone female
bulldozer operators and quickie divorce. But for the most part
it's an idiosyncratic blueprint for a sort of unwieldy socialist
super-democracy, with everything managed by "popular congresses"
(but not parties--parties are evil) who come to a common
agreement without electing anyone (because "representative
democracy" is equally evil). Everything belongs to the people.
Everybody gets universal social services. Nobody owns anything or
makes more than his neighbor. The workers own the natural
resources. As long as OPEC was strong and the nation had a $9,000
per capita income, this was all fine. When that fell to $2,000,
of course, the system came apart at the seams.
But let's not dwell on that. Let's recall Qadhafi's glory
years, the seventies, when there was no country too small (has
any other country signed a mutual defense pact with Guinea?) or
too large (he sent bags of money to redneck presidential brother
Billy Carter) for Qadhafi to get his hands dirty. What's strange
about these years is that you can't figure any overarching
PURPOSE in any of it, except perhaps Destabilizing the Entire
Universe, like some villain in a James Bond movie. He was
constantly trying to form Arab super-states by merging with
Syria, merging with Egypt, merging with Chad and Sudan, but then
withdrawing and sometimes DECLARING WAR ON his former allies when
it became apparent that he couldn't be the leader of the whole
chain of McArabs. He was so disappointed in Egypt, homeplace of
his spiritual mentor Nasser, that he built a 200-mile-long wall
to protect Libya from what had become, overnight, an infidel
country because of its acceptance of Israel. In the Iran-Iraq war
he intervened on the Iran side, even though the population of
Libya is overwhelmingly Sunni. He broke off relations with Saudi
Arabia over the "U.S. occupation" there, even though any plan for
his pan-Arab dream relied on goodwill with the Saudis. He bought
massive amounts of armaments from the Soviet Union, thereby
betraying his Chechen comrades, and kept up a constant war of
nerves with his MIGs playing chicken with American recon planes
near the Libyan coast. When oil was discovered in the
Mediterranean, halfway between Libya and Malta, he declared that
the territorial waters of Libya included everything up to 12
miles from the Maltese shore--a position that almost resulted in
war. He invaded Chad--in order to force Chad to be his friendly
partner. He sent some dirty-tricks squads to Nigeria that caused
an outbreak of violence, leaving 100 dead.
And he had an affection for resistance fighters and
revolutionaries everywhere, no matter whose side they were on. To
give you some idea, he funneled money and arms to SCOTTISH
revolutionaries. (What do THOSE meetings look like? I imagine six
kilted geezers at a banquet table in Inverness.) Some of his
revolutionary largesse seemed to fit in with his pan-Arab goals--
the Moros of the Philippines, the Palestinians--but others were
just plain wacky: radical Indians in South America, the New Jewel
Movement in Grenada, the IRA (!), the Basques, the Kurds (so much
for Iraq joining the super-Arab state). He had a special fondness
for Louis Farrakhan's Nation of Islam, as well as the Black
Panthers, and he tried to give Farrakhan a billion dollars on the
occasion of Farrakhan's receiving something called the Qadhafi
Human Rights Award. (Don't laugh. Libya is the current chair of
the United Nations Commission on Human Rights, in spite of
holding the world record for longest imprisonment of a
journalist--Abdullah Ali al-Sanussi-al-Darrat, jailed in 1973 and
still caged, place of confinement unknown.) The U.S. blocked the
billion, by the way.
What makes this all possible, of course, is oil. Without the
oil, Qadhafi would be one more wacky but ineffectual African
leader. As it is, he's like an International Monetary Fund for
illegitimate governments. He's apparently never met a
secessionist he didn't like, funneling support to breakaway
guerrillas in Chad, Eritrea, Lebanon, the Canary Islands, Wales
(!), Egypt, Sudan, Corsica, Sardinia, and even giving his
blessing to the American Jesus-freak movement Children of God,
which apparently passes muster on the strength of its anti-
government beliefs. (He's been officially declared a messiah by
the Children of God, an honor he accepted reluctantly, apparently
after being convinced it would help his Muslim missionary goals.)
But is he a changed man? He recently turned 61, which
happens to be the average life expectancy for a Libyan, and in
his declining years he doesn't seem so keen on murder anymore. He
was never an indiscriminate assassin in the first place. Like the
Mafia, all killings were kept in the family--people he thought
had betrayed him in one way or another. His notorious Service
Special Des Renseignements--assassins who carried out hits in
Rome, London, Athens, Beirut, Bonn and Milan--had eliminated most
of his chief political opponents by 1980. Most were shot, one was
strangled, and one was decapitated. The decapitation seems to be
his only indulgence in Idi-Amin-style vengeance. For the most
part he's been, by dictator standards, a moderate bloodletter.
Of course, there's the widespread belief that he was
responsible for the explosion that knocked Pan Am flight 103 out
of the air over Lockerbie, Scotland, leaving 271 dead. Even
though he's publicly apologized for it, and turned over two men
to international courts, he's never said he ordered it, and it's
unlikely that he did. When you're supporting various terrorist
cells in every nation on the planet, sooner or later one of them
is going to do something that threatens your oil sales. Perhaps
to make this point, he was the first Muslim leader to condemn Al-
Qaeda after 9/11. "Irrespective of the conflict with America," he
said, "it is a human duty to show sympathy with the American
people and be with them at these horrifying and awesome events
which are bound to awaken human conscience."
The statement was especially significant because it's been
widely assumed that much of his grudge against Europe and the
United States has been intensely personal. His grandfather was
killed by an Italian colonist in 1911. His infant daughter was
killed in a U.S. bombing raid on his personal residence in 1986.
In the days immediately following, he expressed his hatred for
President Reagan in several colorful ways and said it was legal
to EAT American soldiers since they had been revealed to be
animals. He rarely speaks this way anymore, perhaps because his
country has just recently returned from the brink of economic
collapse, perhaps because he doesn't have to. In western
marketing terms, "Qadhafi" is a mature brand, so high-concept
that the word itself inspires allegiances and blind loyalty that
doesn't need further proof of quality. He can afford, like Disney
or Coca-Cola, to diversify without fear of losing his core
business.
This doesn't mean he can't occasionally call for the saber
and the musket, but it usually takes something on the order of an
actual assassination attempt. Ever since 2,000 Libyan soldiers
plotted against his life in 1993--the biggest threat to his power
he's seen so far--he's pretty routinely dealt with the various
opposition figures who want to kill or depose him. One advantage
of being an Islamic, as opposed to Christian or Jewish, dictator,
is that everyone knows upfront that if you try to kill the king,
there will be no trial, no waiting period, no speeches, and no
mercy--you're dead at the moment you're caught. His crack troops,
the Green Guard of the Revolution, handle the necessary
formalities, if any. Qadhafi is avenging one serious
assassination attempt every two years or so, plus the occasional
bloody riot at a football game (a peculiarly Libyan form of
social protest), and even a few foreign-financed jobs. (It now
appears that the 1996 attempt to kill him was orchestrated by
MI6, with help from Al-Qaeda. Now that post 9/11 speech starts to
make sense.)
Otherwise he's lost his flair for the dramatically brutal
gesture. Gone are the days when he suggested torpedoing the Queen
Elizabeth II as it carried Jews to Israel to celebrate that
nation's 25th anniversay. Today Qadhafi contents himself with
repeatedly resigning from office--so that the people can demand
he return--and making apocalyptic pronouncements. (The CIA is
spreading AIDS worldwide. It's the beginning of "The Age of
Chaos." All armies will be destroyed and civilians will be taught
to fight. The coming revolution will start inside America, where
corporations will join with minorities to destroy the government.
Soon world markets will end.) And fortunately for his
international image, he remains eminently quotable: "Israel is
nothing but a mirage, something that does not exist."
In fact, his recent speeches and interviews (if you can call
them interviews--the questions frequently begin with the address
"Great leader!") indicate that he's dwelling on ever more subtle
forms of worldwide disruption. One of his favorite words is
"virus," which he uses in several ways, but the utility of
computer viruses is obviously uppermost in his mind: "Viruses
today are much more stronger than cruise missiles." He openly
gloated over the dotcom bust. And recently he proposed further
destabilizing the western economy by simply counterfeiting
billions of dollars and Euros. Is it just a coincidence that,
since he started talking about it, the U.S. treasury has been
forced to change the designs of its currency, including, so far,
the 100, 20 and 5 dollar bills?
Meanwhile, all his friends from the 1969 Revolutionary
Council have drifted away. Four have retired, one was killed in a
car accident, another was killed in a coup attempt. Abdel Moneim
Al Huni joined the Libyan opposition in 1975 and survived a
Qadhafi hit squad, then--remarkably--reconciled with the Colonel
and is now Qadhafi's ambassador to the Arab League. The man
considered Quadhafi's successor for many years, Major Abdel Salam
Jallud, disappeared from power in the mid-nineties to devote his
attention to business--and he was the last of them. Qadhafi's
various sons all had their problems. Al Saidi is a reckless and
profligate man in his late twenties whose only passion is soccer.
Muhammad, the eldest son by Qadhafi's first wife, is too shy for
the job. Sayf Al Islam, the third eldest son, has served as a
Libyan envoy but reportedly hates politics, and he's been
spending time in Vienna taking business courses at a college
program run by Americans. Only Aisha, now 25, seems to relish
Dad's job. She's appeared on TV with Nelson Mandela, soothed the
nerves of Saddam Hussein during various crises, and once slipped
away from her 30 personal bodyguards at London's Dorchester Hotel
to speak at Hyde Park's Speakers Corner. More important, she can
use the word "privatization" with a straight face while blitzing
European capitals, then become the perfect representative of a
traditional Islamic household at home. It would be somehow very
much LIKE Qadhafi to try to create the first female head of a
Muslim state, and somehow amend the Green Book to allow it.
He doesn't refer much anymore to the Green Book, though,
perhaps because its socialist principles are a little
embarrassing in a country that became steadily poorer through the
nineties, and in fact he's started making a bid for . . .
business partners! At some point he started thinking about
Libya's "1000 miles of unspoiled beaches" and decided he needed
some tourist hotels. (Kind of a long shot, since the country
doesn't accept credit cards and has a permanent ban on alcohol
and gambling.) He's also not ruling out some foreign bank
presences in Tripoli. But he draws the line at joining the
International Monetary Fund or the World Bank, both of which he
despises, because that would be like Disney making a sex film, or
Coca-Cola bottling whiskey. The brand is still strong, but you
can't destroy the franchise. The Q-man may be a little softer in
his old age, but he's not so insane that he would do what appears
to be sane. |